bookshelf

SHOW: / SORT BY: /
Madonna In A Fur Coat
Sabahattin Ali • 1943
Theo of Golden
Allen Levi • 2023

Madonna In A Fur Coat — Sabahattin Ali

"but our missed opportunities never leave us, and every time they come back to haunt us, we ache. or perhaps what haunts us is that nagging thought that things might have turned out differently"

Madonna in a Fur Coat is, at its heart, a story about a missed opportunity, and a man who can't stop aching over it.
Sabahattin Ali hands us Raif Efendi, a withdrawn man whose inner life turns out to be anything but quiet. In 1920s Berlin he becomes transfixed by a painting of a woman, a Madonna in a fur coat, and the longing it stirs in him is overwhelming. His emotions pour out raw and tender, page after page. The catch is that they only ever pour out in his head.
Because here's the thing about Raif: he can love a painting completely. A painting asks nothing of him. It can't reject him, can't be disappointed, can't demand that he be brave. Maria can. And Maria, strong, independent, refusing every role a woman of her time was handed, is everything the painting can't be: real, present, looking back at him. So when he finally stands in front of her, all that feeling dies in his throat. He goes silent.
The two of them are mirror images. She carries a boldness he can't summon; he carries a tenderness most men around him bury. They recognize something in each other. But recognizing it and reaching for it are two different things, and that gap is where the whole book lives.
That's what frustrated me and the more I sat with it, the more I realized the frustration is the point. Raif is fluent in feeling and mute in expression. The wanting is safe; the having terrifies him.